[by Ben Adams]
Don DeLillo is known as a literary curmudgeon.
Suffice it to say he makes public appearances with great hesitance and many grievances; you can almost see him protesting onstage. He detests trivialities involving his work, and when pressed will pass on questions or give blunt one-word answers. So, when I was allowed to be a part of this class knowing he was going to speak, I was overjoyed. Delve Seminars are always a treat to the mind and soul, a place of community and joy. This one was no different, but in this reflection I will focus more on DeLillo’s appearance at the Arlene Schnitzer Concert Hall, given its rarity.
DeLillo when forced into the limelight is like the classic western movie director John Ford: tireless in his genius and scope, but hopeless in basic human engagement about his work. The shame is that when he chooses to be, he is a great orator with a delightful wit (or so one of the few videos of him available on the internet would lead you to believe). This rare opportunity to see him was heightened by the sickening state of politics, especially given DeLillo’s literary commentary about government, just seven days after the presidential election of Donald Trump.
The buzz leading up to his speech was palpable. The weekly seminars and analysis of DeLillo’s work was a mirror on our society, a dystopia come to life. Everyone in the class felt like his work was scarily on point. DeLillo’s novels are known for chastising consumerism, violence, xenophobia, myopia, and oversaturated ratings-driven media consumption. His novel White Noise includes the quote:
“What good is knowledge if it just floats in the air? It goes from computer to computer. It changes and grows every second of every day. But nobody actually knows anything.” (pg. 143)
He has discussed many times the world leaning on the precipice of disaster, one more regime away from destruction. In White Noise it is the literal “noise” of the television buzzing in the background of every home— empty conversation, the possible noise of death, like an electrical transformer, along with the arrival of a physical toxic cloud.
Andrew Proctor from Literary Arts introduced the Don DeLillo talk on the verge of tears. There was our own toxic cloud in the room that night, rising all the way up to the hundred-foot domed ceiling. I won’t mince words: racism, poisonous rhetoric, the breakdown of the media as an outlet for truth, and just utter ignorance had won the election. There were already talks of racist white nationalists being moved into the new cabinet (Steve Bannon). Everyone was curious how DeLillo would respond; I could hear the whispers while we waited for him to take the stage that night. Would he take it as a soft punch, a challenge, would he glare back, or would he shrug his shoulders and proclaim he had warned of this years ago? Would he take the Terrance Hayes (another Literary Arts alum) approach and challenge the predominantly white Portland crowd to actually do something about what they saw?
As DeLillo has said, “It is so much simpler to bury reality than it is to dispose of dreams”. (Americana, pg. 334)
In White Noise the main character is a professor of Hitler studies. The book makes clear human fascination with our own evils and what a danger an uninformed populace can be, as well how an authoritarian can rise to power. I speak for everyone in that crowd when I say we expected a lengthy discussion on the subject.
What we got wasn’t a lion’s roar, but a death-sigh. A depressive dismissal of any sort of discussion. He didn’t even want to sweat it. His nonchalant mannerisms and aloof tendencies were obvious the moment he came onstage. His aging voice quivered at times. It seemed like he wanted to talk about his new book Zero K and be done with it. I was honestly a little sad. Don’t get me wrong, it was a once in a lifetime experience and I am forever grateful to Literary Arts, but I saw an opportunity of privilege wasted that night.
In his book Point Omega which we covered in class, a beautifully stylized yet horrifying fever dream of a novel, there is this quote:
“He said we do this all the time, all of us, we become ourselves beneath the running thoughts and dim images, wondering idly when we’ll die. This is how we live and think whether we know it or not. These are the unsorted thoughts we have looking out the train window, small dull smears of meditative panic.” (Point Omega, pg. 3)
And that is how I felt about DeLillo at that moment onstage. Perhaps his fight was gone, or his anger was private, or he was in shock himself, or in his mind the audience weren’t the ones he needed to go on a tirade to. Regardless, I saw him in a meditative panic. His words had come to life, and perhaps that haunted him. Masses of mostly white rural people, guided by racism, fear, and lack of education; large families—communities—of people rejecting facts and gaining power via gerrymandering; a calculated tyranny of the minority by political deception.
DeLillo might have summarized it like this:
“The family is the cradle of the world’s misinformation. There must be something in family life that generates factual error. Over-closeness, the noise and heat of being. Perhaps even something deeper like the need to survive… we are fragile creatures surrounded by a world of hostile facts. Facts threaten our happiness and security. The deeper we delve into things, the looser our structure may seem to become. The family process works towards sealing off the world. Small errors grow heads, fictions proliferate… Not to know is a weapon of survival, he says. Magic and superstition become entrenched as the powerful orthodoxy of the clan. The family is strongest where objective reality is most likely to be misinterpreted.” (White Noise, pg. 81)
We live in a world on the brink of oblivion or utopia, and the country we live in is economically leading that plunge headfirst into the future, demise by our own design. We have racist/misogynistic government systems on every level, with a greater number of people incarcerated than any other country on earth (targeting disproportionately those of color), a failing education sector, mass misinformation campaigns, and a severely broken political system. There is little hope to be had except by those strong wills around you gleaning onto that last drop of it. Or as they might call it: survival.
Honestly it was hard to focus during the seminars. The political climate and depressing nature of the work we were studying made it difficult to muster up answer to questions. We too were a part of DeLillo’s novel, our worlds overlapping… and yet, myself and DeLillo, white men, are the least affected by all of this, until our death of starvation or old age we will always hold that privilege, and the only logical thing may be to use it for some good. I guess I hoped DeLillo would use that night in some way to impart hope to the audience, to tell fans of his that there was light at the end of the tunnel, that he wanted to help.
I wanted anything but the slouched shoulder sigh of defeat I perceived that night. But perhaps this is just me. Perhaps I am still in need of life lessons necessary to understand why, like every DeLillo character.
I realized his writing isn’t an explanation of anything really, but a mirror pushing the bitter parts of humanity back at itself. With a little clown make-up and a big smirking smile, he shows us the worst of ourselves in a literary package for our unnerving, for our unwrapping.
“Cities were built to measure time, to remove time from nature. There’s an endless counting down, he said. When you strip away all the surfaces, when you see into it, what’s left is terror. This is the thing that literature was meant to cure.” (Point Omega)
I think often of his book White Noise and how it plays so well into the future it now belongs to. The obsessive-compulsive nature of connecting the modern dots to personal disaster (for one DeLillo character it is hair loss and cancer tied to toxic substances around the house); the minute details of technology eroding away personal freedoms (the white noise of technology and looming death); the technological embarrassment of riches that gives us access to everything while robbing of us of wonder and empathy–so perfectly stated in this quote from White Noise:
“Another postmodern sunset, rich in romantic imagery. Why try to describe it? It’s enough to say that everything in our field of vision seemed to exist in order to gather the light of this event.”
So now we have become that which we have glorified and feared for years: a true futurist’s dystopian society in need of saving, in need of destruction or salvation, progression and rebirth. I see so much in the future of society, in its youth, so much hope, so many open hearts. I fear for their education, though, for their freedom, because the two are inexorably linked. Perhaps technology has removed us from the visceral emotion to do something against suffering, has made us so numb and overloaded we sit in our well fed, white privileged pedestals telling others what to do on the internet instead of digging our hands into the community and imparting any gifts we have on equal grounds. To understand systemic systems of oppression, white fragility, misogyny, and to do something about it, right here, right now.
I know this isn’t the average write up for Literary Arts. I know it isn’t a happy read. But I want to take this moment to thank Literary Arts for what they do. It is an invaluable organization bringing the community education, thoughtful discussion, public spaces to meet and share feelings, a place for ideas. Literary Arts is a conduit for public events that challenge us in many different ways. A book can contain stories that transform themselves inside the individual into empowerment, empathy, understanding. The right book in a child’s hands is a piece of potential energy, personal liberty, a sense of community.
DeLillo’s work, at the end of the day, conveys some sort of panicked solidarity in spite of it all:
“How strange it is. We have these deep terrible lingering fears about ourselves and the people we love. Yet we walk around, talk to people, eat and drink. We manage to function. The feelings are deep and real. Shouldn’t they paralyze us? How is it we can survive them, at least for a little while? We drive a car, we teach a class. How is it no one sees how deeply afraid we were, last night, this morning? Is it something we all hide from each other, by mutual consent? Or do we share the same secret without knowing it? Wear the same disguise?” (White Noise)
I think in the end, even facing the clutch of authoritarianism, all we can do is find common ground to raise each other up, to impart any skills or privilege we have into the community, and open our ears to the disenfranchised members of society, truly listening without opinion. The prejudice systems in place only grow stronger now with each passing day, the answer to the meaning of life is your community, as this is where an individual can have the most impact towards change.
Reading and conversation with Anastacia-Reneé and Ashley Toliver
October 19, 2018
Join us for a reading and conversation with Ashley Toliver and Anastacia-Reneé…
Stranger in the Pen
October 25, 2018
panel discussion featuring Mohamed Asem, Dana Ghazi, Ramzy Farouki, and Dr. Priya…
Lit Crawl® Portland, 2018
November 9, 2018
Join us for the official kick-off party for the Portland Book Festival,…
2018 Portland Book Festival presented by Bank of America
November 10, 2018
Join Literary Arts for the annual Portland Book Festival (formerly Wordstock), presented…
The Moth Mainstage in Portland
December 10, 2018
The Moth returns to Portland on Monday, December 10. This extraordinary performance…
Everybody Reads 2019: Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie
March 14, 2019
In partnership with the Multnomah County Library and The Library Foundation, Literary…