[by Phillip Coates]
The discussion this week began with a review of sorts, of how far we have come with these characters, and how far we still have yet to go. We retraced the footsteps of the murder and subsequent fallout by discussing the discoveries we have experienced as opposed to what we expected to unfold in the book. After the review, we discussed a very explosive scene that takes place in part five of the novel that could be best described as the meal from hell. What is meant to be a meal to celebrate the life of a fallen character turns into arguably one of the most contentious scenes in Crime and Punishment. Katerina Ivanovna’s simultaneous derision and praise of her guests could have only lead to misery.
Another important moment is that Raskolnikov finally admits the truth to someone, even almost to himself. He goes through a rollercoaster of motives ranging from robbery, to bitterness, to glory (or a belief that true greatness is borne of violence), and even to simply daring. He eventually realized for him it wasn’t about the act of proving greatness to others, but trying for it himself. What ultimately remains true is that Sonya and Raskolnikov live in their own created realities, yet neither can truly empathize with the other. They can only pity one another. They are not a Venn diagram of intellect, or of agreeable consciousness, but two opposing forces.
Pity is a large motivation in this book. Raskolnikov even gives his money away to strangers out of pity, and not out of goodness, while pity manifests itself differently in Sonya through a savior complex. She relates to Raskolnikov with a hate the sinner not the sin mentality, but additionally I believe Raskolnikov is a person living psychologically and physically constricted. The murder is an eruption from how he could have, and was expected to, live his life.
Liar’s League PDX
October 21, 2017
Liars’ League PDX invites you to attend an evening of imaginative fiction…
Bookmark: A Benefit for Literary Arts
October 25, 2017
Click here to visit the event landing page. Bookmark: A Benefit for…
Fireweed Blossoms: A Literary Celebration and Community Gathering
November 1, 2017
Join us at Literary Arts for a multigenerational community celebration to honor the release…
2017 Wordstock: Portland’s Book Festival
November 11, 2017
Join Literary Arts for Wordstock: Portland’s Book Festival, our annual celebration of literature.…
The Moth Mainstage
December 11, 2017
The Moth returns to Portland on Monday, December 11. This extraordinary performance…
Everybody Reads 2018
April 5, 2018
In partnership with Multnomah County Library and The Library Foundation, Literary Arts is…